Tesla, We Have Questions
For Immediate Release September 4, 2014
Contacts: Bob Fulkerson firstname.lastname@example.org 775-348-7557
Greg LeRoy email@example.com 202-232-1616 x 211
Bob Fulkerson of the Progressive Leadership Alliance of Nevada and Greg LeRoy of Good Jobs First issued the following statement regarding reports that Tesla plans to announce it has chosen Nevada for its "gigafactory," or massive electric-car battery factory.
This is a huge event in Nevada history. If the taxpayer subsidy package for the facility is $500 million or more, as Tesla has demanded, it would be the biggest subsidy package in Nevada history by a factor of more than five. (There is only one recorded eight-figure deal in Nevada history and none over $89 million.)
The announcement only raises more questions:
- Was the five-state auction all just a charade to extract bigger subsidies from the state Tesla had already chosen? (Tesla broke ground in an industrial park in Reno, Nevada in July.)
- If it was a charade, does that mean Tesla doesn't need any Nevada subsidies because the business basics drove the project to Reno (which has good access to key material inputs and is also close to Tesla's assembly facility in Fremont, California)?
- When will the full details of the proposed Nevada subsidy package be released to the public? How many days will Nevada taxpayers have to weigh the costs versus the benefits before the legislature votes on the deal?
- Will Tesla agree to the Good Jobs First/MoveOn petition demand and allow all five states' commerce agencies to immediately release their Tesla project files so that taxpayers can see how seriously Tesla considered the other states and how much in subsidies each state offered?
- Exactly how does Tesla's claim of 6,500 new jobs break down? How many would be temporary construction jobs? How many would be permanently directly employed by Tesla? How many would be associated with unnamed suppliers? (Tesla and Panasonic's joint July 31 press release says half the space will be occupied by suppliers.) Are any of the 6,500 projected jobs indirect or so-called "ripple effect" jobs?
- How good will the Tesla jobs be? What will be the median wage for non-managerial production workers? What will the benefit package consist of?
- Will Nevada taxpayers be protected by "clawback" language that would require Tesla to refund some or all of the subsidies (and/or lose future subsidies) if the deal fails to deliver all of the promised jobs?
- How many of the engineering and other highly-paid jobs at the plant will be filled by people who will move to the Reno area from out of state?
Until these questions are answered, Nevada taxpayers will remain in the dark. Without answers, no one will be able to judge if Nevada elected officials are overspending for a trophy deal.